My opinion
You are a good looking guy but you are "bland" - you have zero edges to compete against other good looking guys like you in your area.
Pic 5 makes you look like a sad dad.
There is an arms race for Apps, any edge that gets explored become exploited by everyone so making it useless.
Good photos, enticing bio ( and yours it's the opposite) and a profile that is telling a "story" is the minimum requirement today.